There is an infinite amount of combinations of notes, keys, instrumentation and rhythms to avail of and some bands insist and going down the path well trodden. The Clientele not only go down the path well trodden but pace back and forth on its most worn out section. Strange Geometry is a disappointingly average album.
Merge Records
Vocalist Alasdair MacLean's singing on this album is fairly desolate sounding. I don't get much feeling from the way he sings, it's more like he's singing like that because by convention that's how a singer in such a song should sound. The Clientele rely too heavily on sounding like bands such as The Byrds and Bob Dylan that they don't sound like themselves. I’m all for paying homage to your influences once you put an original spin on your music. A few times I had to check the sleeve notes to see if they were playing a cover, for example on “Losing Haringey” I was convinced they were covering a Tindersticks song but it turned out to be an original.
The songs themselves are technically well put together. The sound is good and everyone is playing the right note at the right time. It sounds too right though, just like MacLean’s singing there is little passion in the music. There’s also little variation, for instance the same tremolo effect is on the guitar for the entire album. Yes it’s a nice sound but it gets boring after a few songs. Even when they try and freak out they sound like they’re just going through the motions. On “E.M.P.T.Y.” there is what sounds like an aborted guitar solo. It might have had more of an effect if it wasn’t pushed so far back in the mix that it sounds like it’s coming from next door. It's odd because the rest of Strange Geometry is mixed fairly well but to put something that sounded good out of the way seems like madness to me.
The Clientele obviously have talent, they know their instruments and how to get the sounds they want from them. However there is something lacking from the music, they remind me more of a tribute band or an obscure band from back in the day that didn't quite make the big time than a recent band. Strange Geometry does very little for me, it is too bland and sounds like too many albums that I already own.
samples:
Read More
